Catalystas: Beatrice Maneshi
Between October and November 2021, Catalystas conducted a gender and conflict-sensitive Stakeholder Mapping, Baseline Study, and Research Study in support of the launch of a transformative and impactful forthcoming program promoting Freedom of Religion and Belief (FoRB) in Iraq. The research, focused through our intersectional feminist approach, was undertaken on behalf of Catalystas’ client Search for Common Ground (Search) who, in consortium with Tearfund, Mensen met een Missie (MM), and local partners Peace and Freedom Organisation (PFO) and other local partners, make up the members of the Joint Initiative for Strategic Religious Action (JISRA) program in Iraq.
The JISRA project, which is currently scheduled for implementation in 7 countries around the world between 2021-2025, specifically aims to:
- Work within religious communities to challenge discrimination, extremist tendencies, and hate towards others;
- Facilitate and strengthen bridges between religious communities by encouraging inter-religious action and addressing common grievances; and.
- Engage with local, national, and international authorities to make state action towards religious freedom more effective and to challenge divisive policies and practices.
Our team applied our intersectional feminist approach, coupled with our expertise in post-conflict development and our widespread network in Iraq, to conduct a fast-paced, three-part assessment over November and December 2021. Working with a team of 19 researchers, we set out to achieve the following objectives:
- Determine pre-program conditions and set targets against which future changes can be measured in the project;
- Provide inputs on the validity of the project’s Theory of Change (ToC)
- Provide recommendations on adjusting the project strategies,
- Provide direction and inputs to develop a learning plan to coincide with the project, and
- Provide specific recommendations on practical, evidence-based approaches to advocacy campaigns specific to Iraq. Enhance the knowledge and learning agenda for the program as a means to support evidence-based advocacy.
- Provide recommendations on creating accountability to the end beneficiaries and the end donor, the Dutch Ministry of Foreign Affairs.
With the project on a very short timeline, our team needed to cover a vast area of work and subject matter in a comprehensive and efficient manner – addressing the over 26 different religious groups and sects identified across the 3 locations of the study. We started by designing our research methodology through a participatory approach, with a goal of ensuring effective transfer of ownership and knowledge to the project’s implementing consortium partners who will ultimately be responsible for all project components over the next 5 years. After our initial inception phase, during which we designed more than 10 unique data collection tools, our team created a self-led training complete with video instruction, handbook, and quiz series to prepare and certify our team of 19 locally based enumerators in our Catalystas Ethical Guidelines for Data Collection: Interviews, Focus Group Discussions, and in-Field Observation Techniques – a training that will be made available to the general public soon!
After selecting, meeting, and training our research team, we set out to map 360 key actors across the target locations; survey 508 respondents (religious actors and general community members) both in-person and through social media channels; undertake 100 key informant interviews (KIIs) with community leaders, religious leaders, and security actors; and conduct 25 Focus Group Discussions (FGDs) consisting of a total of 200 community members, and organized by gender (mixed and separate), age, and religious denomination with an emphasis on conflict and cultural sensitivity.
Our Catalystas team utilized our extensive track record of work in Iraq alongside our experience in conducting remote research to manage the progress of the study, working alongside our trusted local program coordinators and conducting daily rapid data analysis, reviewing raw data, mapping findings, and adjusting our tools and protocols accordingly in real time. This ensured our ability to not only address any in-field challenges immediately, but also to adjust our processes to include newly discovered information, verify and elaborate on particular findings, and collect any additional data needed. Our team went above and beyond simply providing inputs to feed into a global system for monitoring and evaluation; we looked to utilize both quantitative and qualitative information in order to provide a baseline with clear indicators and means of measurement tailored to the Iraqi context, and taking into consideration the complexities of individual and collective identities and behaviors in the dynamic and rapidly shifting security context in each program location. As a result, our team produced a 90-page baseline study and integrated research analysis as a single living document. This expansive report identified and extrapolated into a rich narrative the exceptionally complex dynamics and juxtaposition of religious, political, ethnic, and historical narratives and identities of the local communities, as well as the academic, religious, security, and political actors engaged.
The final report is currently being translated into Arabic and Kurdish, as a means to transform the findings into easy to use and accessible products. The JISRA-Iraq’s project team will be able to utilize these materials for years to come as they move forward to implement programming that seeks to support tolerance and co-existence when it comes to freedom of religious belief among diverse Iraqi communities.
Catalystas provided the following the services for Search for Common Ground:
- Research and Scoping Studies
- Feasibility Study
- Pilot & Strategy Planning:
- Baseline, Midterm, and Endline Evaluation
- Perception Surveying & Analysis:
- Evaluation Framework and Indicator Review